Availability Heuristic
Don't trust your gut.
A mental shortcut I read about, from Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman, which I've observed in many conversations since, is the availability heuristic. Imagine somebody asks you what the chances are of event X happening to you. You should use statistics like population prevalences and base rates to answer this logically, but humans tend to substitute this question with one they can visualize better, like how easily I can think of an example of this happening.
This, in part, explains why a plane crash seems scarier than a car crash, even though the number of casualties they cause and their frequency differ by orders of magnitude. It's much easier to remember events that are plastered all over the media than more ordinary events.
The availability heuristic states that people judge the likelihood or frequency of an event by how easily examples come to mind. Availability is one reason why people argue against generalizations and averages with their anecdotes. If you say most people who do not pursue post-secondary education will not start multi-million or billion dollar businesses, someone might say their friend dropped out of university and started a $100M+ business. The vivid anecdote is easier to hold in their head than the average, which could be abstract to people who aren't used to thinking statistically.